The Basics

Opened: 2011
Neighborhood: St.Matthews-Crescent Hill border; Middletown
Self-description: “The first coal-fired pizza in the state of Kentucky.”
Website: coalsartisanpizza.com

Best of Louisville Stats

Total nominations: 5
Total wins: 2
First win: 2012, Best Italian Restaurant
Also won: 2014, Best Pizza

The Voting Academy Says

“Not only do they have great pizza named after Louisville neighborhoods, but they have the stuffed mushrooms I dream about.”