The Basics

Opened: Dating back to 1867 (and the days of milk deliveries), rejuvenated in 2015
Neighborhood: Multiple locations, including downtown and the Highlands
Self-description: “Ehrler’s is a name that fills locals with nostalgia.”
Website: ehrlers.com

Best of Louisville Stats

Total nominations: 5
First nomination: 1990, Best Ice Cream

The Voting Academy Says

“It was always a highlight at the Fairgrounds, so when they opened a shop again, I screamed. (See what I did there?) As a kid, I remember going to the Ehrler’s on Breckenridge Lane, our station wagon filled with neighborhood kids.”